The art of the comment: will your expert quote make the final cut?
What makes an expert quote worth keeping?
Two questions that come up a lot when I am writing features are: When will the piece be published, and why didn’t my expert’s comment make the final cut?
To answer both, it helps to know what happens between a freelance journalist pitching an idea and the finished piece appearing. By the time I ask an expert for comment, quite a bit has been happening behind the scenes.
The process
I pitch an article idea to an editor whose inbox is probably bursting with press releases and pitches. I may get a response eventually if they like the piece and want to commission me. This can take up to a week, but sometimes it’s longer. Sometimes I have to chase them and may get a ‘yes’ or a ‘maybe’ (in which case I take on board their comments and write or repitch accordingly). If it’s a ‘no’, I will either ditch it or repitch it elsewhere. This depends on a lot of factors, including how strong I feel the story is, whether it’s still relevant and whether I feel I can get a commission for it elsewhere. A good PR will know to work with the journalist on this process, but not chase unnecessarily.
The pitch
A well-researched pitch can easily take up to a day to finesse. Many of my features for the nationals are human case study-led pieces, and I will definitely need to speak to a case study in advance, to include quotes in the pitch and also to make sure they are ‘real’ (see below). I’ll often find these case studies myself, but if a PR has a case study that will bring the story to life, that really helps. Generally, case studies need to be verifiable and available for interviews and photos. If you send me a quote, make sure it is something they actually said. Please don’t write the quote for them just because it fits the story. I want to hear how they would tell it.
The interview
I generally speak to experts and case studies on the phone or Teams. Sometimes I take written comment (if I know the organisation and PR), depending on deadlines and availability. In that case, I will send you some questions in advance.
Publication
If the above has all gone to plan, and my piece is published, there is something really important to bear in mind. Generally, a freelance journalist will not know when the piece is being published, especially for the nationals. It could be a week, or it could be three months. We do not have any more insight into this than you do. I generally try to give a heads-up when I can, but often your guess is as good as mine.
Why didn’t my comment make the final cut?
This is a tricky one to answer. I usually get more expert comments than I can use. A perfectly good quote can go because someone else has made the point better, or because the focus of the piece has shifted or simply because there isn’t enough room.
As a journalist, I am rarely looking for a summary of the change or issue that I am covering in that feature, as I will have researched these myself, and I am not looking for you to regurgitate them. Instead, I am looking for opinion and real-world experience. How has the issue I am writing about affected your work in practice? How does your opinion add to their story?
If you are pitching to a particular journalist, read a few of their features. Look at which experts they quote and what those quotes add.
Three top tips for PRs and experts
1. Tell me if the case study has been offered elsewhere
I had a situation recently where I was given a case study, interviewed them and found out a few days later that they had already spoken to another publication. This is the quickest way of alienating a journalist.
If we have agreed a case study is exclusive while I pitch the feature, please tell me straight away if that changes. It can affect whether an editor will commission the piece.
2. AI is not your friend when it comes to comments
I have covered this in my Q&A with Antonia Welsh in the context of press releases. While I am not averse to AI being used to help draft a longer press release, I do have an issue with expert comment, which has quite clearly been drafted using AI. There are signs, generally, including an overly long explanation of the policy or legal change, and little opinion or insight. While I appreciate there can be pressure to just send me something, anything, especially if the actual expert is too busy, I would advise against it. I don’t even mind if the quote is badly worded, but give me something new and human.
3. Futuregazing is key
It’s a well-known fact that journalists can struggle to conclude a feature, especially a long feature. And so, a comment which does the job for them, by providing a look into the future and how the issue they are writing about is likely to evolve, is like gold dust.
Think beyond what is happening now to what the eventual outcome of this latest change could be, and don’t be shy about being controversial. The worst that could happen is that you make it into the final copy.
To find out more about how I can help you with your media relations and content, take a look at my services page.